Source: Vanity Teen
Skims sold a $148 advent calendar the internet calls serial killer trophies (hair ties and keychains), then tracked down every single buyer and offered a refund or credit to spend in store. That's more follow-up than most small businesses will give their Black Friday clients. Welcome to a storytime about how to get clients to rebook after the rush, before you spend another November rebuying them.
The doors open on Black Friday. New faces pile in for the deal. The card machine has tapped 412 cards by noon and is now warm enough to toast bread on. Everyone goes home happy, including the new client, who you will never hear from again.
The numbers back this up. Constant Contact just published its holiday survey of more than 1,800 small business owners and 2,600 shoppers in Canada, the US, the UK, Australia and New Zealand. Three findings sit side by side:
75% of shoppers plan to buy from a small business they've never tried this season.
More than 70% of owners have no plan to invite those new shoppers onto an email list or loyalty programme.
Only 39% plan to send a follow-up offer in the new year.
Source: Constant Contact holiday survey, 2026
Last year's edition of the same survey found 88% of shoppers were likely to become repeat customers after a holiday purchase. Different year and sample, same story: shoppers are willing to come back. Most owners aren't planning to ask.
However, Skims was still collecting names. After the backlash, the calendar stayed listed on its site with a waiting list shoppers could join. Even the flop got a list. Yet, more than 70% of owners won't start one for the clients who loved the deal.
(Fair warning: Constant Contact sells email marketing, so they have a horse in this race. The numbers still match what I see in owners' businesses: lots of effort on getting found, empty email lists, and a lot of praying for word of mouth.)
Why the second visit gets skipped
The deal is the fun part. The promo gets 14 planning meetings. The follow-up gets a sticky note and whatever energy is left on December 2. Skims moved faster than that. One TikToker said his refund-or-credit email arrived before the calendar did.
Discounts are the top holiday tactic for 38.1% of owners, and 52.6% of shoppers say sales decide where they buy. Fine. Use them. Just know what a discount teaches: come back when there's a sale. If the only plan after Black Friday is waiting for next Black Friday, you'll pay to win the same client twice.
This month I read a thread from a med spa owner planning a Botox happy hour every Friday through the holidays, plus two weeks of Black Friday packages. A Thursday promo in October had already pulled in plenty of new clients. Great plan for getting people in. The question I'd ask before launch: how many of October's new clients have booked again?
Run the Wince Test before you run the promo
I ran this play in tech and for small businesses. I worked at a software company where people signed up for the free trial and left the day it ended. We kept losing them because nobody reached back to help. They looked to us as the experts, and we weren't acting like experts.
So we changed that. We built a customer education program that taught free users how to make money in their own businesses with the tool, and we asked our existing customers to share what had worked for them, because they were two or three steps ahead. One was a nurse who'd run an ear clinic for 21 years and made $15k on her first course launch. That's when free users turned into monthly subscribers, and monthly subscribers turned into annual ones. Monthly revenue tripled that quarter.
Your business doesn't need a free trial for this to work. I call it the Wince Test, and the five steps spell it out. No new software required.
Live Wince test. Source: GIPHY
W: Weigh the comebacks. Count last month's first-timers. Now count how many came back. If that second number makes you wince, sort that out before you buy more first-timers.
I: Inspect the receipts. Your reviews already tell you why people return, or why they don't. Note the exact words clients use, then borrow those words for your own messages.
N: Nudge them back. Line up three messages before the rush: a thank-you within a day, a review request, and a reminder before they're due again.
C: Confirm the next visit. Book it before they leave, or tuck the booking link into the thank-you. Luxury gets bought on want, not on a schedule, so give the want a date.
E: Extend the invite. A happy holiday client knows other people who'd love the same deal. Ask them who they'd bring.
Source: She is Epic
The expensive part is already done
Getting a stranger through your door takes ads, discounts and more reels than anyone should have to film. On Black Friday, a discount and a busy weekend do it for you. Asking that person back costs a text message.
The owners who'll have a good January are the ones who nail down this week what happens after the first visit. Everyone else will be back here next November, buying the same clients again at full price.
Skims gave every buyer a reason to come back and shop. You only have to text yours to give them a date.
Fair's fair: I just told you to ask people back, so I'm asking you. Take the five-question 50 First Bookings quiz and see where your first-timers slip away.
[ the master plan ]
How do you get clients to rebook after Black Friday?
Plan the second visit before the sale starts, or you'll pay to win the same client twice. Constant Contact's holiday survey found over 70% of small business owners have no plan to invite holiday shoppers onto an email list or loyalty programme. Run the Wince Test: count last month's first-timers who came back, line up a thank-you, review request and reminder, and book the next visit before they leave.